Why Does He Do That? Inside the Minds of Angry and Controlling Men

A narrative walkthrough of the book’s core ideas.

Lundy Bancroft

13 min read
1m 42s intro

Brief summary

Why Does He Do That? argues that abusive behavior in relationships is a conscious choice rooted in a mindset of entitlement and control, not an uncontrollable emotional problem. It reveals how controlling men think and manipulate reality to maintain power.

Who it's for

This is for anyone seeking to understand the mindset behind a partner's controlling, angry, or manipulative behavior.

Why Does He Do That? Inside the Minds of Angry and Controlling Men

Audio & text in the Readsome app

How Controlling Partners Think

The root of abusive behavior in a relationship has surprisingly little to do with how a person feels and almost everything to do with how they think. While many believe that mistreatment stems from deep-seated emotional pain or a lack of self-control, Lundy Bancroft explains that the core of the problem lies in a partner's belief system. These individuals process their emotions through a lens of entitlement and a desire for control. This creates a Jekyll and Hyde transformation, where a charming, supportive man suddenly becomes a harsh critic who uses insults or intimidation. This confusion is not accidental; by keeping a partner in a state of constant uncertainty, a controlling person maintains power and avoids taking responsibility for their actions.

The foundational reality of this mindset is the desire for dominance. Bancroft describes a client named Glenn who destroyed his partner’s important college paper as a punishment because she planned to move out. Glenn felt entirely justified because he believed he had the right to penalize her for seeking independence. The problem is not that the man loses control of himself, but that he takes control of his partner. He expects his partner to provide constant physical and emotional caretaking. If she tries to focus on her own interests, he views her as a servant failing to do her primary job, which he believes is keeping him happy.

This mindset often involves a total reversal of reality. When a partner tries to defend herself against an attack, the abuser often labels her actions as the primary aggression. For example, a man named Emile attacked his wife, and when she tried to protect herself, he claimed he was the victim of her violence. This distorted logic allows the abuser to avoid accountability by making it seem like the partner is the one causing the conflict. To continue his behavior without feeling guilt, he must strip away his partner's humanity. Over time, his conscience adapts to his cruelty, allowing him to treat his partner with a level of disrespect he would never show to a stranger or a coworker.

Because controlling partners often present a sympathetic face to the world, they frequently use denial and distortion to hide their behavior. They may claim they only yelled because their partner provoked them, ensuring the focus remains on the victim's behavior rather than their own choice to be hurtful. Breaking free from this confusion requires shifting the focus away from the partner’s needs and back onto one's own well-being. By stripping away the excuses and the performative apologies, an individual can begin to see the situation clearly and reclaim their own life.

Full summary available in the Readsome app

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store

About the author

Lundy Bancroft

Lundy Bancroft is an author, workshop leader, and consultant with over thirty years of experience in the fields of domestic abuse and child maltreatment. He is a former co-director of Emerge, the first counseling program in the United States for men who batter, and has worked with over a thousand abusive men as a counselor and clinical supervisor. Bancroft's work focuses on accountability for abusive men, the healing of women and children, and training for professionals, including judges, therapists, and law enforcement, on best practices for intervention.

Similar book summaries